The final night’s offering at Lislea was from the Sillan
Players of Castleblaney and was Frank McGuinness’s Carthaginians, a most
complex, layered, metaphorical and allegorical play.Indeed far too much so for most teams of the
confined circuit, and this it proved to be.
On the night the cast wasted time in setting the right
atmosphere, threw away lines at critical moments, failed to convey the primacy
of truth-telling in the hoped-for resurrection – and when the time came, the
revelations largely went unnoticed in the audience - and indeed the audience
generally missed the point of the whole exercise.When the adjudicator gave a reasoned
explanation of the MacGuinness play and its intent prior to his critique, I
felt I had sat through a different production.
Rightly the team’s Producer won the award for staging the
most challenging play. But then they
took the premier award also!
Paradoxically (at least, I thought so) the Best Producer went to Kerry
Rooney of Lislea (he also won Best Supporting Actor).
Surely the contest is all about the premier award going to
the best production? They are separate awards, I know, but rarely
go to different teams and I suspect such division of honours is indicative of
indecision on the part of the adjudicator.
Lislea – I believed unfairly –
took runners-up position.
I felt confident of a home win for I thought Lislea had the
stronger team on stage.Other
adjudicators agreed but our judge, John McArdle of Castleblayney felt that
Castleblayney had the edge.
For the record, the other awards on the night went to :
Best Actor : Ger Liston of Ardagh, who played the part of
the Altzimers-suffering Dad in A Quiet Moment : this play also had “Best Moment
of Theatre” and theAudience Award and
Best Stage Management and Best Character Portrayal
Best Actress : Eva Fidgeon who played Greta in Sillan’s
Carthaginians.
After yet another very successful Festival, my admiration
for, and appreciation of Lislea, its Drama Company and its Festival Committee
and all the supporters of this tiny rural community remains undiminished:
indeed it is further enhanced!